Fine structure of the low-frequency spectra of heart rate and blood pressure
© Kuusela et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2003
Received: 21 May 2003
Accepted: 13 October 2003
Published: 13 October 2003
The aim of this study was to explore the principal frequency components of the heart rate and blood pressure variability in the low frequency (LF) and very low frequency (VLF) band. The spectral composition of the R–R interval (RRI) and systolic arterial blood pressure (SAP) in the frequency range below 0.15 Hz were carefully analyzed using three different spectral methods: Fast Fourier transform (FFT), Wigner-Ville distribution (WVD), and autoregression (AR). All spectral methods were used to create time–frequency plots to uncover the principal spectral components that are least dependent on time. The accurate frequencies of these components were calculated from the pole decomposition of the AR spectral density after determining the optimal model order – the most crucial factor when using this method – with the help of FFT and WVD methods.
Spectral analysis of the RRI and SAP of 12 healthy subjects revealed that there are always at least three spectral components below 0.15 Hz. The three principal frequency components are 0.026 ± 0.003 (mean ± SD) Hz, 0.076 ± 0.012 Hz, and 0.117 ± 0.016 Hz. These principal components vary only slightly over time. FFT-based coherence and phase-function analysis suggests that the second and third components are related to the baroreflex control of blood pressure, since the phase difference between SAP and RRI was negative and almost constant, whereas the origin of the first component is different since no clear SAP–RRI phase relationship was found.
The above data indicate that spontaneous fluctuations in heart rate and blood pressure within the standard low-frequency range of 0.04–0.15 Hz typically occur at two frequency components rather than only at one as widely believed, and these components are not harmonically related. This new observation in humans can help explain divergent results in the literature concerning spontaneous low-frequency oscillations. It also raises methodological and computational questions regarding the usability and validity of the low-frequency spectral band when estimating sympathetic activity and baroreflex gain.
The existence of spontaneous fluctuations in heart rate and blood pressure has been known for a long time in modern cardiovascular physiology . The spectral analysis of heart rate and blood pressure is a widely used noninvasive technique to assess autonomic indexes of neural cardiac control [2–4]. Such analyses typically focus on three separate frequency bands: a high-frequency (HF) band, a low-frequency (LF) band, and a very-low-frequency (VLF) band; the standard frequency ranges of these bands are usually >0.15 Hz, 0.04–0.15 Hz, and 0.003–0.04 Hz, respectively. The selection of these bands reflects the assumption that each is related to a certain cardiovascular mechanism [5–9]. In normal conditions the presence of a spectral peak in the HF band of RRI spectrum is closely related to respiration and is attributed to vagal mechanisms. Another frequency peak in RRI spectrum can be found within the LF band, which is attributed predominantly to sympathetic mechanisms but partially also to vagal mechanisms. It is often reported that this frequency peak is centered on 0.1 Hz (also called Mayer waves), but the frequency of this oscillation and the underlying mechanisms are still uncertain. Oscillations at frequencies in the VLF band are often related to the vasomotor tone of thermoregulation or to the dynamics of hormonal systems, but the origin and frequency of the oscillations in this band are still unknown.
It is widely believed that a single peak in the entire spectrum reflects a specific mechanism of cardiovascular control which can be quantitatively measured by determining the area under that peak, i.e., the corresponding spectral power. However, there are many studies suggesting either that a single peak can originate from a complex set of various control mechanisms, or that a single control mechanism can produce several peaks [8, 10, 11]. Additionally, it is known that both the amplitude and frequency of the oscillations within VLF, LF, and HF bands can vary with the physiological conditions [12–14].
This study investigated the details of the spectra of the R–R interval (RRI) and systolic arterial blood pressure (SAP) in the LF and VLF frequency ranges in order to characterize the principal frequency components in healthy humans. Three spectral methods based on totally different mathematical approaches were used; the use of several methods is crucial to validation of the results. We have not explored possible mechanisms behind each frequency component, but we do discuss the phase conditions between RRI and SAP in the VLF and LF bands.
Subjects and study protocol
A total of 12 healthy subjects (age 20–26 years) participated in the study. The study protocol was approved by the ethics committee of the Tampere University Hospital. The actual protocol consists of several different phases, but only two of them were used in this study. In the first phase (lasting 12 minutes), the subjects were studied whilst breathing spontaneously. After this phase the spectrum of the respiration flow signal was calculated and the peak frequency was determined. In the second phase (lasting 12 minutes), the subjects were studied using metronome-controlled breathing where the breathing frequency was adjusted to the value of the peak frequency of the respiration flow from the first phase. This arrangement guaranteed that in the second phase all subjects could breath at their natural breathing frequency so that the breathing frequency did not vary significantly. The spontaneous breathing frequency varied from 0.12 Hz to 0.25 Hz. Before the first phase there was 15 minutes adaptation time to stabilize the hemodynamics, and there was a 5-minute rest period between the first and second phases. In all recordings the subjects were in supine position. Since the subjects were forced to follow the metronome sound it was possible to verify that they were not asleep.
The following data were measured: ECG (Rigel 302 Cardioscope), continuous noninvasive blood pressure from the left middle finger (2300 BP Monitor, Ohmeda Inc., USA), pulmonary air flow (M909, Medikro Oy, Finland), expiration CO2 and O2 concentrations by capnometer (Datex Normocap, Datex Inc., USA), and oxygen saturation at the left ear lobe (Datex Satlite, Datex Inc. USA). All signals were digitized at a sampling rate of 200 Hz (WinAcq data acquisition system, Absolute Aliens Oy, Finland). The RRI time series were generated by detecting the R peaks of the ECG signal, and the SAP and diastolic pressure time series were generated by finding the corresponding beat-to-beat minimum and maximum on the blood-pressure signal within each RRI. All data analyses were performed with WinCPRS software (Absolute Aliens Oy, Finland).
The choice of spectral methods used in this study was critical to the detection of any fine structure in the RRI and SAP spectrum within the LF range below 0.15 Hz. There are two main factors that must be considered carefully. First, in spectral analysis the frequency resolution is higher when longer time series are used, but only if the system under study is stationary over the time interval of the analysis, and in the present study we cannot make any assumptions in regard to the stationarity of the system a priori. If the system varies significantly in the parameter space, the spectrum calculated over a long time interval is an averaged result, and hence any small time-varying details in the oscillatory patterns of the signal will be lost. Secondly, if the analysis method used in the spectral calculations provides us with the necessary frequency resolution, using a very short time series in our analysis increases the likelihood of capturing the true structure of the spectrum in the case of a nonstationary signal. The problem is how to assure that a representative sample of the signal is used. One solution is to calculate several short-term spectra, and search for patterns that can be found on all of them. We have done this by calculating the spectra using a sliding time window of reasonably short duration and a time step that is much smaller than the window width. Since it is rather unlikely that there are sudden or abrupt changes in the heart-rate or blood-pressure regulation system, especially when the subjects are studied whilst supine, we can assume that RRI and SAP spectra vary only slowly. When tracking the position of the dominant frequency components we can easily recognize the fundamental modes since the corresponding spectral peaks will appear as continuous paths on the time–frequency plots.
We applied three methods to the spectral analysis of RRI and SAP time series: Fast Fourier Transform (FFT), autoregression model (AR), and Wigner-Ville distribution (WVD). We selected these methods because they are based on totally different mathematical approaches and therefore their combined use increases the likelihood of validating our results. Detailed description of each of these spectral methods can be found on Appendix (see Additional file: 1). AR method is most suitable for searching the principal frequency components since the spectrum can be easily decomposed using pole-expansion of the spectrum. In contrast, with FFT or WVD method it is difficult to determine accurately the positions of the spectral peaks. However, the use of AR method is also problematic since the essential parameter of it, the optimal model order, is difficult to determine. Therefore we have used non-parametric FFT and WVD methods to help us for finding the best model order: the model order of the AR spectrum was adjusted in such a manner that the overall shape of the spectrum resembles FFT and WVD spectra. FFT and WVD spectra have typically reasonably high spectral resolution in the low frequency range but poor statistical relevance. The latter one can be improved by smoothing the spectra but then we decrease frequency resolution. This unavoidable trade-off between statistical relevance and resolution complicates detecting spectral peaks reliably: spectra can include spurious features. However, since FFT and WVD spectra are computed using different mathematical approach it is very unlikely that these features appear simultaneously on both spectra, and therefore the combined used of FFT and WVD to resolve the optimal AR model order is crucial.
Principal frequency components of the R–R interval. Mean frequencies of the first three spectral components of the R–R interval for frequencies below 0.15 Hz.
Coherence, phase and gain between RRI and SAP. The mean RRI-SAP coherence, mutual phase difference, deviation of the phase difference and transfer function gain for each principal frequency component below 0.15 Hz (computed by the sliding FFT analysis) and for the LF frequency band (computed withing the LF band using a single data segment and coherence>0.5 condition). Each value is the mean(SD) over 12 subjects.
Phase deviation [degrees]
Our main findings are as follows: (1) below 0.15 Hz there were at least three distinct peaks in both RRI and SAP spectra; (2) principal spectral components around the frequencies of 0.026 Hz, 0.076 Hz, and 0.119 Hz were found in all subjects; (3) the lowest spectral peak around 0.026 Hz was remarkably similar in all subjects and it did not vary over time; (4) the frequency of the other two main peaks clearly varied over time, but only slightly; and (5) the phase difference between the SAP and RRI was clearly negative and almost constant over time and the coherence was high in the case of the two highest frequency components, but in the case of the first component the phase and coherence did not exhibit stable characteristics.
Our approach to combine three different spectral methods proved to be successful. AR method has superior frequency resolution if the model order is properly set, and the principal spectrum components can be easily computed. Commonly used information criteria to estimate the model order are inadequate, as we demonstrated in this study. In the most cases WVD spectra was useful for searching the optimal model order of AR spectra but sometimes we needed also FFT method to recognize the main features of spectra. Since the frequencies of the 2nd and 3rd principal components are not constant it is not possible to capture them using only single data segment, thus spectra should be computed as a function of time to uncover these components.
The presence of spectral components around 0.026 Hz in both RRI and SAP data is well known, and are widely believed to be related to the dynamics of thermoregulatory processes . However, the precise frequency of these oscillations has not been reported previously. In our study this oscillation mode was found in all subjects over a remarkably narrow frequency range. The corresponding period of about 39 s could, in principle, be an artifact of our analysis, such as being generated by the specific width of the time window used in our computations. To check this we also performed the analyses using considerably shorter and longer sliding windows, and found that this had no significant effect on the frequency. Since the coherence and especially phase between the SAP and RRI at this frequency varied over time, it is unlikely that this oscillation is a part of the blood-pressure regulation system, so it can be regarded as a secondary effect of some other mechanisms.
The existence of two or more distinct oscillatory components in the LF band was a striking observation. In the literature there are no specific reports of multiple spectral components in this frequency band in humans. In most cases the explanation is very simple: overall spectral power has been used as a measure of sympathetic activity, and detailed spectral composition has not been the target of the studies. It is very difficult to distinguish close spectral peaks using FFT analysis when sliding time windows are not used. Previous studies that have used AR modeling employed model orders that were too low to allow close peaks to be discriminated, as we have demonstrated. However, in animal studies there are some interesting reports on the presence of two spectral peaks within the LF band. Cevese et al.  investigated spontaneous fluctuations in heart rate and blood pressure in anesthetized dogs with the left iliac vascular bed mechanically uncoupled from the central circulation. They found individual peaks in RRI and SAP spectra at 0.03–0.07 Hz and at 0.12–0.17 Hz, and in some cases there was simultaneously a peak in both frequency ranges. They suggested that the simultaneous peaks are simple harmonics of each other and that there is a unique causal mechanism behind this phenomenon. However, careful inspection of their data does not support this conclusion. In our data the two spectral peaks were not simple harmonics. Another interesting observation on oscillations well below 0.1 Hz has been reported recently . In that human study alpha-blockade intervention produced a new spectral peak in some subjects centered at 0.04–0.05 Hz during which the "normal" peak around 0.1 Hz disappeared. It is unclear whether this new spectral peak is associated with our findings since the phase difference between SAP and RRI at 0.04 Hz was reported to be -73 to -169 degrees, which is much more negative than our observations at 0.076 Hz. However, that study demonstrated that the spectral composition of RRI and SAP is not necessarily constant in all conditions. It should be noticed that spectral peaks well below 0.1 Hz have been reported in humans also in normal physiological conditions. Especially with very elderly people the LF peak can shift significantly towards lower frequencies [14, 17] but, however, coexistence of two or more clear peaks on this frequency region has not been reported previously. Since all subjects in our study were young and almost equal in age we cannot make any conclusions on the age dependence of the components.
One possible explanation of our findings is that the separate peaks were somehow produced by the respiratory component, either directly as subharmonics or by mixing with other components. These mechanisms would be possible if the system was highly nonlinear, but this is not very likely since in our experiments the respiration frequency was fixed by an external metronome and was different for all subjects, and despite this we found two separate peaks both within a relatively narrow frequency range.
It should be noted that there are no a priori physiological conditions or requirements for only one spectral peak to be found within the LF band. Although the origin of LF rhythms in blood pressure and heart rate is still mostly unknown, two theories – the feedback theory and the central theory – have been considered the most probable. Both theories can support the existence of several spectral components in the LF band. Our findings do not elucidate a valid underlying mechanism, but they do suggest that the underlying system is more complex than commonly believed. Since the mutual coherence is high and the phase angle is clearly negative for both components, we cannot exclude the possibility that they are generated by baroreflex-mediated control. The diverse results in literature on the frequency of oscillations of RRI and SAP in the LF band and the corresponding baroreflex-related latency times can be simply reflections on the fact that there exist two distinct component: sometimes the first one can be more dominant, sometimes another one. Thus the existence of two simultaneous well-determined oscillations in the LF band gives rise to an important question about whether we can simply use the spectral power to quantitatively estimate sympathetic activity or the transfer-function approach to measure baroreflex gain. Our results indicate that the phase differences and gains between RRI and SAP related to two principal frequency components are significantly different. Phase and gain values computed by the commonly used method, i.e. applying analysis on a single long data segment, seem to be approximately average (perhaps weighted by coherence) of ones of the separate components. Therefore currently used spectral method can be basically valid but the reliability and reproducibility can be rather poor since we don't know how various physiological situations, age of the subject and other factors modulate these two components. Our results clearly indicate that more detailed analysis should be used when using spectral measures to estimate sympathetic activity and baroreflex sensitivity.
The data provided here indicate that the standard LF range of 0.04–0.15 Hz contains two frequency components, not one as widely believed, and that these components are not harmonically related. This new observation in humans can help explain divergent results in the literature concerning spontaneous LF oscillations. It also raises some methodological and computational questions regarding the usability and validity of the LF spectral band when estimating sympathetic activity and baroreflex gain. Time-frequency analysis should be performed in order to check if there are several distinct components in the LF band of RRI and SAP spectra. If several components can be observed all essential spectral measures, like spectral powers, phase differences, latency times and gains, should be computed for each component separately and compare them with the ones determined normally from the single data segment.
This work was supported by the Academy of Finland and the Medical Research Fund of Tampere University Hospital.
- Koepchen HP: History of studies and concepts of blood pressure waves. In Mechanisms of blood pressure. Edited by: Miyakawa K, Koepchen HP, Polosa C. 1984, Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 3-23.Google Scholar
- Parati G, Saul JP, Di Rienzo M, Mancia G: Spectral analysis of blood pressure and heart rate variability in evaluating cardiovascular regulation. Hypertension. 1995, 25: 1276-1286.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- James MA, Panerai RB, Potter JF: Applicability of new techniques in the assesment of arterial baroreflex sensitivity in the elderly: a comparison with established pharmacological methods. Clin Sci. 1998, 94: 245-253.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pitzalis MV, Mastropasqua F, Passantino A, Massari F, Ligurgo L, Forleo C, Balducci C, Lombardi F, Rizzon P: Comparison between noninvasive indices of baroreceptor sensitivity and the phenylephrine method in post-myocardial infarction patients. Circulation. 1998, 97: 1362-1367.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hyndman BW, Kitney RI, Sayers BM: Spontaneous rhythms in physiological control systems. Nature. 1971, 233: 339-341.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Akselrod S, Gordon D, Madwed JB, Snidman NC, Shannon DC, Cohen RJ: Hemodynamic regulation: investigation by spectral analysis. Am J Physiol. 1985, 249: H867-H875.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pagani M, Lombardi F, Guzzetti S, Romoldi O, Furlan R, Pizzinelli P, Sandrone G, Malfatto G, Dell'Orto S, Piccaluca E, Turiel M, Baselli G, Cerutti S, Malliani A: Power spectral analysis of heart rate and arterial pressure variabilities as a marker of sympatho-vagal interaction in man and conscious dog. Circ Res. 1986, 59: 178-193.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Saul JP, Berger RD, Albrecht P, Stein SP, Chen MH, Cohen RJ: Transfer function analysis of the circulation: unique insights into cardiovascular regulation. Am J Physiol. 1991, 261: H1231-H1245.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Malliani A, Pagani M, Lombardi F, Cerutti S: Cardiovascular neural regulation explored in the frequency domain. Circulation. 1991, 84: 482-492.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Akselrod S, Gordon D, Ubel FA, Shannon DC, Barger AC, Cohen RJ: Power spectrum analysis of heart rate fluctuations: a quantitative probe of beat-to-beat cardiovascular control. Science. 1981, 213: 220-222.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Berger RD, Saul JP, Cohen RJ: Transfer function analysis of autonomic regulation. I: canine atrial rate response. Am J Physiol. 1989, 256: H142-H152.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Di Rienzo M, Castiglioni P, Mancia G, Parati G, Pedotti A: 24 hour sequential spectral analysis of arterial blood pressure and pulse interval in free-moving subjects. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 1989, 36: 1066-1075. 10.1109/10.40813.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Parati G, Castiglioni P, Di Rienzo M, Omboni S, Pedotti A, Mancia G: Sequential spectral analysis of 24-hour blood pressure and pulse interval in humans. Hypertension. 1990, 6: 414-421.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Di Rienzo M, Parati G, Castiglioni P, Omboni S, Ferrari AU, Ramirez AJ, Pedotti A, Mancia G: Role of sinoartic afferents in modulating BP and pulse interval spectral analysis in unanesthetized cats. Am J Physiol. 1991, 261: 1811-1818.Google Scholar
- Cevese A, Grasso R, Poltronieri R, Schena F: Vascular resistance and arterial pressure low-frequency oscillations in the anesthetized dogs. Am J Physiol. 1995, 268: H7-H16.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cevese A, Gulli G, Polati E, Gottin L, Grasso R: Baroreflex and oscillation of heart period at 0.1 Hz studied by α-blockade and cross-spectral analysis in healthy humans. J Physiol. 2001, 532: 235-244.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Parati G, Frattola A, Di Rienzo M, Castiglioni P, Mancia G: Broadband spectral analysis of blood pressure and heart rate variability in very elderly subjects. Hypertension. 1997, 30: 803-808.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article: verbatim copying and redistribution of this article are permitted in all media for any purpose, provided this notice is preserved along with the article's original URL.